HR or Personnel? Whats the difference? | Consensus HR in Herts, Beds
Our Latest blog: What is the difference between Human Resources. (HR) & Personnel?
At Consensus HR, one of the comments we generally get asked is “What is the difference between Personnel & Training and Human Resources? they are the same aren’t they?
In answer to these questions, we have put together the following blog. The shift from “Personnel and Training” to “Human Resources” (HR) reflects a broader evolution in the field, emphasising a more strategic and comprehensive approach to managing an organisation’s workforce. Here’s a detailed comparison of the two terms and their implications:
Personnel and Training
Personnel Management:
- Administrative Focus: Personnel management traditionally has an administrative and operational focus, dealing with day-to-day employee management tasks.
- Record Keeping: Emphasis on maintaining employee records, handling payroll, and ensuring compliance with labour laws and regulations.
- Employee Relations: Managing employee relations, handling grievances, and ensuring workplace discipline.
- Reactive Approach: Often reactive, dealing with issues as they arise rather than proactively planning for the future.
Training:
- Skills Development: Focuses on providing training programs to develop specific skills and competencies required for employees to perform their jobs.
- Short-Term Focus: Generally, has a short-term perspective, addressing immediate training needs rather than long-term development.
Human Resources
Human Resources Management (HRM):
- Strategic Focus: HRM takes a strategic approach, aligning the management of people with the overall goals and strategy of the organisation.
- Holistic Management: Encompasses a broader range of functions, including recruitment, talent management, employee development, performance management, and succession planning.
- Proactive Approach: Proactively addresses workforce planning, employee engagement, and organisational culture.
- Employee Experience: Focuses on improving the overall employee experience, from onboarding to career development and retention.
Key Differences:
- Scope and Focus:
- Personnel and Training: Primarily administrative, focusing on compliance, record-keeping, and training for immediate needs.
- HR: More comprehensive, encompassing strategic planning, talent management, and aligning HR practices with business goals.
- Approach:
- Personnel and Training: Reactive, dealing with issues as they arise.
- HR: Proactive, anticipating and addressing future workforce needs.
- Role in the Organisation:
- Personnel and Training: Often seen as a support function, primarily handling administrative tasks.
- HR: Viewed as a strategic partner, contributing to the organisation’s long-term success.
- Employee Development:
- Personnel and Training: Focuses on specific training programs to address immediate skill gaps.
- HR: Emphasizes continuous learning, career development, and long-term talent management.
- Terminology:
- Personnel and Training: Uses terms like personnel management, employee records, and training programs.
- HR: Uses terms like talent management, human capital, employee engagement, and strategic workforce planning.
Evolution of the Field
The transition to “Human Resources” reflects the evolving recognition of employees as valuable assets (“human capital”) whose development and engagement are critical to organisational success. This shift acknowledges that effective management of human resources contributes significantly to achieving competitive advantage and driving business growth.
My HR Comment / Advice: Personnel or HR? What do you refer to it as?
Matthew Chilcott, Owner of Consensus HR comments: “In summary, while “Personnel and Training” focuses on administrative and operational tasks related to employee management, “Human Resources” represents a more strategic, comprehensive, and proactive approach to managing an organisation’s workforce, recognising employees as key contributors to the organisation’s success.”
Consensus HR encourages clients to have a policy in place that covers all areas including:
What is it referred to within your business? Personnel or HR? Talk to Matthew at Consensus HR and discuss!”
Further information on my past experience can be found on my LinkedIn profile.